Makita DTD171 vs DeWalt DCF870N-XJ – Best Impact Driver for Builders in 2025?
Choosing between the Makita DTD171 impact driver and the DeWalt DCF870N-XJ (18V XR) can be tough. Both are high-performance cordless impact drivers trusted by tradies across New Zealand.
This review breaks down the key differences, pros and cons, and performance results so you can decide which one is right for your toolkit.
Makita DTD171 Impact Driver Review
The Makita DTD171 is one of the most advanced impact drivers in the LXT lineup.
Key features:
- 18V LXT brushless motor
- 180 Nm max torque
- 4 speed settings + 4 assist modes (including wood, self-tapping screw, and bolt mode)
- Ultra-compact design at just 116mm long
- Dual LED lights for visibility
- Lightweight at 1.2kg (bare tool)
Pros (Makita DTD171):
- Extremely compact – great for tight spaces
- Multiple assist modes prevent overdriving and stripping
- Lightweight and ergonomic for long use
- Huge LXT battery ecosystem
Cons (Makita DTD171):
- Slightly less torque than DeWalt
- Pricey compared to Makita’s entry-level drivers
DeWalt DCF870N-XJ Impact Driver Review
The DeWalt DCF870N-XJ (part of the 18V XR range, similar to the DCF887) is built for raw power and durability.
Key features:
- 18V XR brushless motor
- 205 Nm max torque
- 3 speed settings + PrecisionDrive mode
- Compact at 134mm long
- Strong LED work light
- Weighs 1.34kg (bare tool)
Pros (DeWalt DCF870N-XJ):
- Higher torque (205 Nm) for heavy-duty tasks
- Durable XR build quality
- 3-speed control with PrecisionDrive
- Widely available in NZ and worldwide
Cons (DeWalt DCF870N-XJ):
- Bulkier than Makita DTD171
- Fewer modes than Makita
- Slightly heavier
Which Impact Driver is Better in NZ?
Pick Makita DTD171 if you want:
Compact size for tight spaces
Precision assist modes
Lightweight tool for all-day use
Pick DeWalt DCF870N-XJ if you want:
Maximum torque for tough jobs
A rugged, heavy-duty driver
To expand your XR platform
Overall verdict:
The Makita DTD171 is best for builders who need control and versatility.
The DeWalt DCF870N-XJ is best for tradies who prioritise raw power and toughness.
FAQs – Makita DTD171 vs DeWalt DCF870N-XJ
1. Which has more power, Makita or DeWalt?
The DeWalt DCF870N-XJ delivers 205 Nm torque, more than the Makita DTD171’s 180 Nm.
2. Which is lighter and more compact?
The Makita DTD171 is smaller (116mm) and lighter (1.2kg), making it easier to use in tight spaces.
3. Which impact driver is better for DIY?
Both work well, but the Makita DTD171’s assist modes make it more beginner-friendly.
4. Is the DeWalt DCF870N-XJ the same as the DCF887?
Yes – the DCF870N-XJ is a regional model designation, but performance is very similar to the popular DCF887.
5. Which brand has the better battery platform in NZ?
Both Makita LXT and DeWalt XR have massive tool ranges. The choice depends on which batteries you already own.
Final Thoughts
If you want precision, lightweight design, and control, go with the Makita DTD171.
If you need power, toughness, and higher torque, the DeWalt DCF870N-XJ is the way to go.
Either way, both are among the best impact drivers in NZ for 2025.